Why not to have a vasectomy

Approximately one in 11 men regret, or at least temporarily regret, having had a vasectomy. This figure rises to one in seven men under the age of 30. Only a small fraction of these men proceed to vasectomy reversal. In the following article, I will outline the possible reasons against having a vasectomy.

‍

__wf_reserved_inherit

You may have decided that it is time to have a vasectomy and have come to this website to book one. Over the next few minutes, I will try to change your mind and explain why you might not want to proceed with a vasectomy.

The three most important questions to discuss with your partner

  1. What happens if your relationship ends and a future partner wants children with you? (This is common in Western societies.)
  2. What if you or your partner change your mind? (This occasionally happens even in stable relationships.)
  3. What if something happens to one of your children? (Rare, but particularly important for younger couples.)

If you do not currently have a partner, you should be aware that failing to disclose a prior vasectomy to a future partner would almost certainly result in your partner being granted a divorce, with all associated legal implications.

Further questions to consider

When thinking about this procedure, you should also ask yourself:

  1. Have I genuinely sat down with my partner and considered all alternatives? There are several excellent alternative contraceptive methods available. Sometimes it is worth waiting a little longer before proceeding. Long-acting reversible contraceptives, such as the coil or implant, can safely postpone a permanent decision.
  2. Am I at an age where I do not want any children, regardless of future circumstances?
  3. Do I already have enough children, or do I or my partner still have unspoken wishes?
  4. If my life circumstances changed and reversal was unsuccessful, would adoption be an option I could consider?
  5. Am I at an age where sperm freezing should be considered?
  6. Am I so worried about vasectomy that it may not be the right option for me? There are excellent female contraceptive alternatives available. It is not a failure if you decide not to proceed. If you have read both the clinical and personal FAQs on this website and still feel uncertain, you may wish to reconsider.

Medical contraindications to vasectomy

  1. Intrascrotal hernia (must be repaired before vasectomy)
  2. Lack of mental capacity (a court order is required, initiated by the person holding Power of Attorney for medical care)
  3. Poorly controlled diabetes (HbA1c greater than 69)

Factors associated with increased risk of problems, pain, or regret

There are several important clinical issues we need to be aware of in order to counsel patients appropriately and minimise the risk of disappointment, complications, acute or chronic pain, and long-term problems.

  1. Severe obesity (BMI over 35): These patients can be more difficult to operate on and have higher infection rates. A prior assessment appointment is recommended.
  2. Diabetes: Good HbA1c control is essential to reduce the risk of postoperative complications. Infection rates are higher in poorly controlled diabetes. If HbA1c is 69 or above, diabetes must be managed before any elective surgery, including vasectomy.
  3. Smoking: Smokers have a significantly increased risk of infection (up to 400% higher). We recommend stopping smoking at least 3–4 weeks before vasectomy. Current evidence suggests vaping is less harmful than smoking.

Patient groups at higher risk of pain, complications, or regret

Certain personality types and clinical situations are associated with poorer outcomes:

  1. Patients with high anxiety levels, feelings of being pressured into the procedure, or a generally negative outlook tend to do less well and have a higher risk of post-vasectomy pain (PVP) or regret.
  2. Patients on long-term pain medication, particularly opioid- or codeine-based drugs, are more likely to experience severe recovery pain and chronic issues, possibly due to hyperalgesia.
  3. Type A personalities with a strong need for control, excessive preoccupation with details, or mistrust of healthcare professionals may struggle to cope with the procedure and recovery.
  4. Patients with PTSD following previous medical trauma are at increased risk of post-vasectomy problems.
  5. Disorganised patients or poor listeners who do not read or absorb provided information often remain anxious due to lack of understanding and may rely on unfiltered online sources instead of structured medical advice.
  6. Diagnosed mental health conditions, such as depression or personality disorders, can negatively affect satisfaction and outcomes.
  7. Patients who are "too busy," frequently change appointments, fail to attend webinars or consultations, or do not complete pre-procedure forms may be displaying anxiety or disengagement, both of which are risk factors for poor outcomes.

Pain perception and anxiety

The same local anaesthetic technique is used for every patient, yet pain scores range from "no pain at all" to, rarely, "excruciating." These scores are recorded five weeks later in post-procedure questionnaires.

Approximately 97% of patients rate the local anaesthetic as causing no more than mild to moderate discomfort.

High anxiety can significantly reduce pain tolerance due to sustained adrenaline levels and heightened mental focus. Very low pain tolerance may also be associated with high anxiety, excessive painkiller use, low resilience, externalising blame, catastrophising minor issues, or exaggerated fear responses. In our experience, these factors predict poorer outcomes after vasectomy and other surgical procedures.

The good news about vasectomy

Having anxiety or a mental health condition does not automatically mean you will have a poor outcome. The risk factors described above are specific and experience-based, not absolute exclusions.

Additional medical considerations

  1. Bleeding or coagulation disorders (e.g. von Willebrand disease or previous bleeding complications) require specialist assessment before vasectomy.
  2. Absence of a vas deferens: This can occur for several reasons and may complicate the procedure. While many cases can still be managed successfully, some may require further exploration, a second opinion, or acceptance that vasectomy is not feasible.
  3. Presence of a third vas deferens: Rare and easily missed, this can lead to failure if not identified. Investigation must be handled carefully to avoid damaging blood vessels.
  4. Testicular cancer: Rare and not an absolute contraindication, but it understandably takes clinical priority.
  5. History of fainting: Usually manageable, but important to identify in advance.
  6. Young age (under 30): Statistically associated with a higher risk of regret.

Why should I be the one to have a vasectomy?

If permanent contraception is appropriate, vasectomy is one of the safest and most effective options. For men who have completed their families, or who are certain they do not want children, and for whom further children would represent a significant burden, vasectomy is an excellent choice.

It allows a partner to stop hormonal contraception and places reproductive control directly in your hands.

Ultimately, the choice is yours.

Share this post
Portrait of senior nurse Leanne in a navy nurse's uniform

Ready to take the next Step?

Book your vasectomy surgery online, or get in touch if you have questions.

Send us an email

Get in touch

Talk to our experts

0202 585656